Words from a grognard

Month: October 2026

Design: Magicking II

With the basics of working spells laid out, we can flesh out more of the system to provide a stronger flavor. One of the ways I’m doing that is to vary how well the caster knows the spell being used, with familiarity having an effect on use.

Spell expertise

There are three levels of expertise when it comes to casting spells: researched spells, known spells, and mastered spells.

Researched spells are those spells the caster is working on, yet to finish. The caster has the research materials and has begun working out the magical patterns involved, so has a basic idea of how to form the spell. That said, the spell isn’t in final form and is unreliable and unpredictable. It likely requires extra time to cast and the caster has to check for miscasting it. A miscast brings fatigue and pyschic damage and the spell may have its effects twisted.

Known spells are those that have the final form worked out and the caster has a bit of familiarity with casting it. The spell still requires some extra time to work and has a slight chance of miscast. It’s full functional, just needs polish and practice.

Mastered spells are those that are well-rehearsed and readily cast. These are the spells that simply operate as described, with reliable results and no real chance of miscasting. The caster has used it enough times that they don’t have to spend much time thinking about how they’re doing it, just go about doing it.

Learning Spells

PCs begin with a mastered spell or two, plus a known spell. I expect developing spells to be a major part of playing a caster, so gaining additional spells is a game loop included during time spent in town. Magicians rarely find any materials that offer a spell in detail, mostly they get notes and have to work from what they already know and work out how to apply the information found in those notes to create a spell they can use. Even a spell found on a scroll doesn’t provide all of the information needed to master it, though it does help speed the process of developing a spell the caster can use.

So the wizard takes the information they’ve assembled and starts working out which magical structures and techniques are likely to work best for them when working magic that achieves the same ends. The vocabulary used, the meter of the lines, structure of the verse, what gestures are needed, what material components, and so on.

I expect PC casters will always have new spells in development, as finding spell descriptions complete with full instructions should be quite rare. The caster’s mentor can set up the PC with a couple of spells that are mastered at play start, and likely a few more that are known. Some materials to use when researching new spells is also believable, with letters of introduction or recommendation to assist in the new wizard gaining access to more materials.

Off-Camera Play

Another concept I want to support when PCs are in Town is that of off-camera play. Gygax mentions it basically in passing in the DMG, when he speaks of the importance of keeping time. He spoke of time passing when a PC traveled to see an oracle, how many days the character would be unavailable for inclusion in adventures when other PCs wanted to go slog around a dungeon. The whole bit was simply to focus on the PC being unavailable, and with the assumed approach to adventuring at the time being one game day equaling one real world day, and keeping track of what days a PC was available was important in continuity. I walked away from reading that, however, with a sense that off-camera play is a thing and wondering how I could use it at my table.

I can’t say that I worked out any solid procedures for it. It rarely came up in play, actually, and certainly not in any way that involved closely tracking travel time or the like, just a general break in adventuring for a couple of weeks until that PC returned. Aside from an assassination attempt, there was never a formal process for even determining how well the trip went (a D20 roll, perhaps). I find now that I really want a formal process for off-camera activities as a part of Town play.

This has a few predicates. First, the activity the PC is engaged in is a solo endeavour; querying an oracle isn’t a team event. Next, what travel is involved isn’t through the wild and wooly Wilderness where adventure hangs from tree limbs and drops on passersby, so traveling with an adventuring party isn’t an expected part of it. I also reckon that the effects of the off-camera play shouldn’t be of primary importance in any group concerns.

The procedure for off-camera activity needs to be able to gauge the time spent in pursuing it as part of managing Town activities as a whole, plus offer choices to the player as the activity is pursued that affect the off-camera activity, other Town activity, or both. The Town cycle is a major part of the game experience I want, so shoring up the supports for it is important.

What’s Suitable for Off-Camera?

The obvious answers are those already found in the DMG, I reckon. If the PC decides to travel through settled lands to query an oracle or personally handle a business dealing or the like, then it can be done off-camera. The actual business or political negotiations can be expressly played by the GM & player without the rest of the group around, of course, though a diced resolution process can serve just as well (leaving live play to full group situations).

Tasks such as an assassination attempt (if one has assassin PCs in one’s game) also fit with off-camera play. If a PC class has diagetic tasks associated with it that don’t fit well in group play, then those tasks are set out as off-camera. A thief casing wealthy estates in a nearby city is an activity best suited to off-camera. Forays involving burglary there may be best suited to off-camera play.

Any time a PC has an individual test or ritual to perform, then playing off-camera is likely the better approach. A monk has to travel to a far site and pass through a gauntlet of tests there to be able to advance in the monkish order, well, that’s a good thing to do off-camera.

[A thought just popped into my head: for those who like character arcs, off-camera play may be a way to include that sort of thing in an old school campaign where individual stories aren’t a focus.]

I guess the question now involves deciding how involved the off-camera procedures should be? Much the same as the on-camera procedures? Flattened a bit to reduce handling time for the GM? Really simple abstractions?

Design: Social Renown & Reputation

Many systems have rendered the idea of character reputation in mechanics, for better or worse…well, most of them for worse, IMO. I was leery of even considering whether I wanted to work reputation rules into my projects because of that. Consider it, I did, however, and I think I’m going to go ahead and put such a subsystem in the projects and see if it survives playtesting.

To place it in context within the projects, I’m approaching social interactions with PCs beginning interactions with NPCs possessed of a neutral or slightly worse reputation out the gate. Their reputation then improves or degrades based on interactions. PCs can have a general reputation based on hearsay and then reputations with individual NPCs based on substantial interactions.

The core of the interaction subsystem is based on the Reaction Table of D&D, though extended in each direction to move hostile reactions and enthusiastically friendly reactions outside the range the dice roll. The reputation table that results from using this base has movement in either direction possible in steps, and it would be rare indeed for any such movement to be more than but a step or two in either direction. PCs will have to do serious work to increase the regard in which they’re held (and behave egregiously bad to tank their reputations).

As the title of this post indicates, I’m also breaking renown and reputation apart in play. I figure the PCs can gain reknown far easier than a better reputation, meaning more people have heard of the PCs for their activities than have had significant interactions to judge them.

That split means that the PCs are likely to be contacted by new potential patrons based solely on their renown, without any reference to reputation. The PCs will thus be held in neutral regard again and again when recruited for some task — getting in the good graces of their new supporters will take much more effort.

Having some measure of renown will increase the PCs’ visibility and lead to more networking opportunities. Developing a positive reputation with influential NPCs will also increase network effects, with positive reputations leading to personal recommendations.

That networking increases access to authorities, nobility (if the setting includes such), mayors, wealthy people … well, pretty much anybody. Now, being well known doesn’t mean all interested parties hold the PCs in any great regard, so just being known isn’t going to result in better treatment, necessarily. It also means the PCs will be noticed by bad guys, for better or worse.

It will prove easier to find sources of information, which I think should be an important part of campaign play. The PCs will need buyers for ancient treasures and sellers of specialized goods, which reknown and reputation can assist with. As I already plan for the liquidation of treasures to involve finding specialized buys and intermediary agents and such, having access to more of each can be seen as essential.

The Base Reaction Table

<= 0 Attack

1 Extremely hostile (will escalate quickly)

2 – 3 hostile

4 – 5 suspicious

6 – 8 guarded

9 -10 calm

11-12 interested

13 pleasant

14+ amicable

PCs will be held in regard in the 6 – 8 range from the outset, with NPCs defaulting to being guarded when interacting. This applies to both immediate interactions and the reputations that result from continued interactions. It is only through play that their reknown grows and reputations improve.

Setting: Recurring Events I

I enjoy having problems arise in the setting that the PCs can deal with in the short term, yet those issues will arise again in the future. I started thinking about this phenomena recently when brainstorming a new adventure, so I’m trying to work out a variety of ways providing a recurring challenge has cropped up in play over the years.

The adventure at hand involves some ancient magical wards failing and a BBEG waking, rousing its minions, and those minions going forth and behaving badly. If the PCs decide to help the locals with this problem, they have to figure out where the minions are coming from, then infiltrate the site and see if they can figure out how to stop it from happening again. They’ll figure out that minions they’ve cut down are respawning and then have to figure out how to stop that from continuing. The BBEG can also be cut down and then will respawn, adding to the mess. The party will have to figure out that the way to prevent recurrence is to restore the wards that failed.

The thing is, I don’t want the plague of minions to be constant, so there has to be a reason for the BBEG to wake and rouse them for a bit and then go absent again for awhile. That took me down the rabbit hole of identifying many ways I’ve handled that, and others GMs have handled it when I played at their tables, and a bit of extrapolation based on that experience to identify other ways.

I’m expecting this adventure to be linked to astronomical events. Thus, I’ve been building a list of events that can certainly be reasonably tied to magical/supernatural events. What I’m offering here isn’t exhaustive, I expect, though every entry is something I’ve brainstormed multiple uses for to decide if it warrants inclusion (as the formal list will be part of a GM’s text).

The Moon

An obvious cycle to tie weird events to is one provided by the moon. Postulating that your setting has a moon generally similar to our own Luna, with noticeable cycles in the viewing, there are many ways to parse it out.

• A full moon for the triggering event. One can use a single day measure or a three-day measure of the full moon for short windows of activity. A longer window ranges from full moon to new moon.

• A new moon works just as well.

• A gibbous moon phase — the time between full moon and half moon — provides a shorter measure of time than full-to-new. A crescent moon phase — half moon to new — does the same.

• One can require that the solution to stopping the recurrence be tied to a moon phase, too. The full moon triggers the event and the measures needed to stop it (semi-)permanently need to happen during the following new moon, for example.

• If your setting includes multiple moons, then things can get wilder. Two moons have to be full or some such. Or all three moons have to align just so. Lots of possibilities here.

The Sun

The next obvious cycles to consider are those tied to the sun. Again, first considering settings that involve a single star similar to Sol. We have historical accounts of numerous cultures observing solar events for matters of importance, with calendar systems being largely tied to solar cycles.

• Soltices are major events and long used to regulate calendar years.

• Equinoxes have also been tied to calendars and religious/cultural celebrations.

• The so-called cross-quarters, halfway between solstice and equinox, have also been tied to celebrations and observances. All Hallows’ Eve — Halloween — is a prime example of this.

Seasons

The travels of the sun in relation to the horizon are tied to the seasons, given an Earth-like world setting. The seasonal changes can drive magical activity, where they don’t perfectly align with the solar cycle. Perhaps winter is measured from the first hard frost instead of the sun’s progress. Spring arrives with the blossoming of specific flowers instead of simply aligning with the sun.

The Stars

Another obvious historical connection is that of events matching up with the stars in the heavens, or stellar constellations as seen from Earth. One can create an entire astrological lineup for seasons, matching up with solar positioning at sunrise, or matching moonrise, or using some other type of recognition of the astrological cycle.

Mix & Match

Now, these are all perfectly good when used by themselves. There’s absolutely nothing stopping a GM from mixing these together, to make sorting out the requirements for a magical sealing ritual a bit more involved. One can posit that a BBEG will awaken during the first new moon after the winter solstice and can only be put to rest on the nights of a full moon thereafter, for example. Or will regenerate after being killed and rise again on the first new moon in each season.

Tying events in adventures to natural cycles in the setting helps deepen the sense of immersion for those who treasure that, and makes things a bit more predictable for even those who don’t worry about deep immersion. The setting comes to life a bit more, as the elements get tied together.

© 2026 OSRPGtalk

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑